|
Claire Short UC Davis graduate, Spring 2022 Major: Wildlife, Fish, and Conservation Biology I often diligently avoid conflicts, which sometimes means being overly polite or letting other people have their way. But when I feel comfortable fully expressing my opinions, I have always hated to back down. When I was a kid, that compelled me to insist for years that “stragedy” was the correct spelling and change the rules of chess so I could un-checkmate myself. Although I do not condone cheating, my years of practice standing my ground and finding creative ways to come out on top fueled a productive debate at a recent lab meeting. When Jessie critiqued the experiment design that Nora and I had proposed in our presentation, Jessie and I began a battle of wits that evolved into a valuable discussion. Nora and I have been designing an experiment to test whether mini pigs can be as effective for therapy work as dogs, which have already been established in the scientific literature as therapeutic. We plan to have three different groups: an experimental group in which participants interact with a pig, a negative control group in which participants talk with the researcher and have no interaction with other animals, and a positive control group in which participants interact with a dog. This will allow us to compare the effects of human-pig interaction with both the pig-free baseline and the human-dog interaction, which we expect to be therapeutic based on previous research. We plan to measure both physiological effects (cortisol levels from saliva, brain activity using a portable electroencephalogram (EEG), and heart rate) and psychological effects (using mood and mental health surveys). Nora and I received mostly positive feedback on our presentation, but Jessie was strongly opposed to the idea of using surveys for psychological measurements. “People will lie,” she said. “They’ll say that the pigs were therapeutic just because they know they’re supposed to be.” I acknowledged that there was some bias inherent in surveys but pointed out that our physiological data would only measure arousal, which could be either positive or negative. When you’re stressed, your cortisol levels and heart rate increase, and your brain has a higher proportion of alert, beta brain waves. But the same physiological reactions can also occur when you’re exuberantly excited. Whether you feel like running towards or away from something, your body needs to prepare for action. “The surveys can help us interpret the physiological data if it indicates arousal,” I argued. “They might not be perfect, but without them, we would have no idea whether people were stressed out or excited by the pigs.” Jessie continued to insist that the data from the surveys would be useless and would only confuse our interpretation of the results. I argued that collecting more data could only make our study stronger, to which Jessie responded: “I just really hate surveys.” Jessie and I had reached a stalemate, but we both refused to admit it. My inner child who couldn’t lose was well-matched with Jessie, who plans to be a lawyer. Although our chess game was unwinnable, we didn’t abandon it until other people started a different game: helping us both improve our respective ideas. One of the interns, Ashley, suggested making the surveys anonymous so that people would feel more comfortable being honest. Inspired by that, I mentioned the possibility of phrasing our questions so it’s not obvious that we expect the pigs to be therapeutic. Although we cannot completely eliminate bias in people’s responses, with some creativity, we can reduce it to make our results more credible. Since Jessie was still not sold on surveys, Becca suggested using behavioral measurements, such as eye contact and other body language, for Jessie’s experiment with the donkeys and ponies. Although this would require labor-intensive video analysis, it would yield valuable data. Clearly, there are many different successful tactics in the game of experiment design. When the meeting ended, we had all won. Thanks to our stubbornness and creativity and an environment where we could safely express ourselves, we had made up our own rules and helped each other improve them. As the interns and I continue the work out the details of our experiments, I’m grateful to have colleagues who will both play me to a stalemate and help me out of one. Together, we will refine our "stragedies" to make our research more powerful.
131 Comments
3/19/2025 12:01:14 am
Great post! I really enjoyed reading your insights. The points you made were thought-provoking, and I appreciate the effort you put into sharing valuable information. Looking forward to reading more of your content!
Reply
5/15/2025 02:07:30 am
Detox in Nashville with trusted professionals who understand your journey. Whether it's drugs or alcohol, our programs are tailored to meet your specific needs, ensuring a smooth and supported transition into recovery.
Reply
9/2/2025 06:20:58 am
Drug detox Atlanta services seem to vary a lot. Some centers focus on medical detox while others on holistic care—curious what works best for long-term recovery."
Reply
9/4/2025 01:07:01 am
Sober living homes in San Luis Obispo seem to offer a really supportive environment for people transitioning back to daily life.
Reply
9/22/2025 10:59:26 pm
Drug detox in Nashville provides a supportive environment for individuals ready to begin recovery. With professional care and personalized programs, clients can safely manage withdrawal and take the first step toward a healthier future.
Reply
10/3/2025 05:37:56 am
Great read! I really appreciate the insights you shared—clear, thoughtful, and engaging. It’s always refreshing to come across content that sparks new ideas and encourages deeper reflection. Looking forward to reading more from you!
Reply
10/4/2025 12:18:02 am
Great read! I really appreciate the insights you shared—clear, thoughtful, and engaging from start to finish. It sparked some ideas for me and gave me a fresh perspective. Looking forward to more content like this!
Reply
10/4/2025 10:56:26 pm
Absolutely loved reading about the creative journey behind these designs! It's always inspiring to see how a concept evolves from idea to print, especially when it blends science and style so seamlessly. Keep up the amazing work—this kind of storytelling makes the tees even more meaningful.
Reply
10/6/2025 01:20:37 am
Great read! I really appreciate the insights you shared—especially the way you broke things down so clearly. It’s always refreshing to come across content that’s both informative and engaging. Looking forward to more posts like this!
Reply
10/8/2025 01:17:44 am
Great read! I really appreciate the way you broke down the topic—clear, insightful, and easy to follow. It sparked some new ideas for me and gave me a fresh perspective. Looking forward to more posts like this!
Reply
10/11/2025 11:51:03 pm
Great read! I really appreciate the way you broke down the topic—clear, engaging, and thought-provoking. It sparked a few ideas of my own and gave me a fresh perspective. Looking forward to more content like this! <a href="https://sites.google.com/view/shop-graphic-tees/home">shop graphic tees</a>
Reply
10/12/2025 06:03:45 am
Great read! I really appreciate the way you broke down the topic—clear, insightful, and easy to follow. It sparked a few ideas for me and gave me a fresh perspective. Looking forward to more posts like this!
Reply
10/12/2025 10:12:43 pm
Great read! I really appreciate the way you broke down the topic clear, engaging, and thought-provoking. It’s always refreshing to come across content that balances insight with personality. Looking forward to more posts like this!
Reply
10/14/2025 12:59:20 am
Thanks for sharing this! It was a really insightful read.
Reply
10/14/2025 11:55:44 pm
Thanks for sharing this insightful post!. It's given me a lot to think about. Looking forward to your next one!
Reply
10/15/2025 01:01:45 am
I love how clearly you explained this topic. Looking forward to more posts like this!
Reply
Great post — thanks for sharing! I learned a lot from this article and especially appreciated the clear examples. If anyone wants a quick, practical follow-up, take a look at <a href="https://pixabay.com/users/4200205/">Pixabay</a>. Looking forward to your next post!
Reply
10/19/2025 11:15:20 pm
Great post! I really enjoyed reading this — you explained everything so clearly. Thanks for sharing your insights!
Reply
10/20/2025 06:46:21 am
Really interesting read! I’ve been thinking about this topic lately too.
Reply
10/21/2025 12:34:52 am
Detox in Atlanta GA provides professional support for individuals withdrawing from drugs or alcohol in a safe, medically supervised environment.
Reply
10/21/2025 11:54:40 pm
Great read! I really appreciate the insights you’ve shared here. The topic is explained clearly and gave me a lot to think about. Looking forward to reading more of your posts!
Reply
10/26/2025 01:21:26 am
Great post! I really enjoyed how you explained the topic in such a clear and engaging way. The insights you shared were very helpful and gave me a new perspective. Thanks for putting this together — looking forward to reading more of your content!
Reply
10/27/2025 01:28:56 am
Great post! I really enjoyed the insights you shared here. Thanks for breaking down the topic so clearly.
Reply
10/28/2025 11:42:37 pm
Great post! I really enjoyed how you explained this topic, simple yet informative. I learned something new today, thanks for sharing!
Reply
11/7/2025 09:27:06 pm
Great post! I really enjoyed how you explained this topic — clear, practical, and easy to follow.
Reply
11/8/2025 08:12:36 pm
I totally agree with your points here! I’ve had a similar experience and your post really resonates with me. Keep up the great work! Thank.
Reply
Really appreciate this article! The breakdown you provided was super helpful and made the subject much easier to understand. I like how you included real examples and kept everything actionable. Definitely bookmarking this. thanks for the value! <a href="https://dog-district-center.creator-spring.com/">Dog Shirt For Human</a>
Reply
11/17/2025 10:21:29 pm
Detox in Nashville includes a range of medically assisted programs focused on helping clients clear harmful substances from their bodies while receiving compassionate care.
Reply
1/22/2026 02:06:00 am
Moldsshop.com offers premium silicone candle, soap, and baking molds along with high-quality DIY craft tools—perfect for handmade, creative, and professional projects.
Reply
1/22/2026 02:06:14 am
CandlesMolds.com offers premium candle molds and candle-making supplies for DIY crafters and professionals to create high-quality, custom candles.
Reply
1/22/2026 06:05:52 am
CandlesMoulds.com offers a wide selection of high-quality silicone and decorative candle molds, perfect for DIY candle makers and craft enthusiasts looking to create unique, professional-grade candles.
Reply
1/30/2026 11:53:20 pm
Wonderful article. Fascinating to read. I love to read such an excellent article. Thanks! It has made my task more and extra easy. Keep rocking.
Reply
1/31/2026 03:09:39 am
This type of message always inspiring and I prefer to read quality content, so happy to find good place to many here in the post, the writing is just great, thanks for the post.
Reply
2/2/2026 06:21:11 am
Very good points you wrote here..Great stuff...I think you've made some truly interesting points.Keep up the good work.
Reply
2/5/2026 05:50:37 am
I think this is one of the most significant information for me. And i’m glad reading your article. But should remark on some general things, The web site style is perfect, the articles is really great : D. Good job, cheers
Reply
2/5/2026 06:15:28 am
Wonderful article. Fascinating to read. I love to read such an excellent article. Thanks! It has made my task more and extra easy. Keep rocking.
Reply
2/6/2026 06:55:59 am
Great article with excellent idea!Thank you for such a valuable article. I really appreciate for this great information..
Reply
2/6/2026 09:47:14 pm
I admire what you have done here. I like the part where you say you are doing this to give back but I would assume by all the comments that this is working for you as well.
Reply
2/8/2026 03:38:44 am
This blog is really great. The information here will surely be of some help to me. Thanks!.
Reply
2/9/2026 05:46:03 am
Thank you very much for writing such an interesting article on this topic. This has really made me think and I hope to read more.
Reply
2/11/2026 11:09:04 pm
Thanks for posting this info. I just want to let you know that I just check out your site and I find it very interesting and informative. I can't wait to read lots of your posts.
Reply
2/15/2026 01:08:50 am
The page sets expectations well about what a visit or service can involve.
Reply
2/17/2026 06:18:38 am
Took me time to read all the comments, but I really enjoyed the article. It proved to be Very helpful to me and I am sure to all the commenters here! It’s always nice when you can not only be informed, but also entertained!
Reply
2/20/2026 02:22:58 am
Professional remediation can reduce airborne spores and improve indoor air quality.
Reply
Greetings! Your focus on the "frictionless movement of value" is a breath of fresh air. Streamlining the path between digital credit and immediate cash is becoming a benchmark for personal financial agility in a world that moves too fast for traditional banking.
Reply
4/5/2026 11:40:58 pm
I absolutely enjoyed every minute of it. I have you bookmarked to see new things you post. It was a great read. Loved coming by.
Reply
4/15/2026 08:37:01 pm
A very awesome blog post. We are really grateful for your blog post. You will find a lot of approaches after visiting your post. I was exactly searching for. Thanks for such post and please keep it up. Great work..
Reply
5/5/2026 02:20:15 am
Great post, you have pointed out some excellent points, I as well believe this is a very superb website.
Reply
5/5/2026 07:32:28 am
Business Setup Services in Abu Dhabi assist entrepreneurs with company formation in mainland and free zones. It covers licensing, approvals, documentation, and complete setup support for fast and legal business establishment in UAE.
Reply
5/8/2026 07:55:59 am
Really loving the collection at The Cotton Leaf Pakistan. The designs are simple, clean, and perfect for daily wear. Glad to see Pakistani clothing brands focusing on quality cotton apparel.
Reply
5/12/2026 01:45:06 am
AC sizing is not just about square footage. Climate, insulation, sun exposure, and ceiling height all affect the final tonnage decision. That is why state-specific sizing guides can be more useful than generic charts
Reply
5/12/2026 01:46:07 am
AC sizing is not just about square footage. Climate, insulation, sun exposure, and ceiling height all affect the final tonnage decision.
Reply
5/12/2026 01:48:37 am
On many washers, a lock-related code does not always mean a broken part. In many cases, the issue is tied to the control lock setting, an interrupted cycle, or a temporary panel response problem
Reply
5/12/2026 01:49:18 am
On many washers, a lock-related code does not always mean a broken part. In many cases, the issue is tied to the control lock setting, an interrupted cycle
Reply
5/12/2026 11:36:08 pm
The format of this post made it easy to follow along without needing to stop and reread anything — everything was well-paced and clear.
Reply
6/4/2026 06:40:53 am
Tài xỉu MD5 là trò chơi cá cược trực tuyến được nhiều người yêu thích nhờ tính minh bạch và kết quả công bằng. Truy cập ngay để trải nghiệm Tài xỉu MD5, tham gia đặt cược dễ dàng và nhận nhiều ưu đãi hấp dẫn mỗi ngày.
Reply
Leave a Reply. |
Green Care Blog
Here you can find blog posts from each Green Care Lab intern. We'll be talking about our research process, the benefits of Green Care therapy, and sharing pictures of our work. Follow along with us! Authors
All
|